Search This Blog

Monday, August 1, 2011

Who you gonna call? Dam busters!

One morning in early March 2011, residents of Ryan Court, Drysdale found contractors digging a large hole at the bottom of their sloping road, immediately outside the last house in the street. They were told that it was to be a 'Bio-retention Basin', which was intended to filter impurities from the storm water running down their street.

This was the first that the residents had heard of this decision. As the residents watched this two-foot deep 'Basin' (effectively, a storm water dam) fill with rainwater that failed to drain away as promised, they tried to discover more about it from the City of Greater Geelong. Council officers gave them the runaround and said that the council had sent a letter to all the residents in 2010 informing them of the decision to create the dam. No-one received such a letter.

The residents asked DCSCA for assistance. as a result, a meeting was held on site between Cr. Rod Macdonald, Mr. David Hannah (CoGG's Manager, Engineering Services), Ryan Court residents and DCSCA's Doug Carson and Patrick Hughes. At the meeting, Mr. Hannah said that the pipe feeding the dam would be turned off within the week, allowing council engineers to examine it.

Subsequent to that meeting, DCSCA wrote to David Hannah on 22 July 2011(copies to Cr. Rod Macdonald and Ryan Court residents), summarising what had been discussed. The following is an extract of that letter:

1. Role of the dam
You said that the dam has been built in accordance with CoGG's requirement that the rainwater run-off from the new estate at the top of the road should be no greater after the development than it was before. This requirement is imposed on every proposed development. CoGG officers assess the plans for each proposed development to ensure that it will not increase rainwater run off and, if the plans show that it won't, CoGG approves the development. CoGG doesn't examine each completed development to ensure that the run off is, indeed, no more than it was previously. Instead, it relies on its engineers' professional assessment of the plans.

Our response.
As you explained this policy, it became clear that the construction of the dam in Ryan Court was part of the proposal to build the new housing estate. CoGG gave planning approval for this estate some time ago, so it is hard to understand why the residents of Ryan Court were given no opportunity to comment on the dam until the morning that contractors arrived to construct it.

Further, the residents have noticed an increase in the rainwater run-off in their street since the estate was built and this, together with the fact that CoGG has built the dam to 'process' that run-off indicates that the run off from the estate has increased and is being off-loaded to Ryan Court, rather than being dealt with in the estate itself. The residents of Ryan Court are suffering the effects of the new, CoGG-approved housing estate, while enjoying no material or financial benefit from it. We would like to see the plans for the new estate that CoGG engineers approved, to see whether they include the dam in Ryan Court.

2. Purpose of the dam
You said that the purpose of the dam is to improve the quality of the water running off the new estate at the top of the road by filtering out 'phosphates' and 'nitrogen'; and that the filters in dams like this are cleaned-out every eight years (approximately). However, you were unable to say by how much the dam will improve the quality of the water issuing from it.

Further, residents said that there have been oil slicks and detergent foam on the surface of the water in the dam (they have photographs of this) and you were unable to state whether the dam's filtering system can deal with such pollutants. Nor could you say whether such pollutants affect the ability of the filtering system to deal effectively with the 'phosphates' and 'nitrogen' it is designed to neutralise. Finally, the residents pointed out that the water going through the dam into the creek at the bottom of Ryan Court is just a fraction of the total amount of water that flows through the creek, which is fed by the run-off from Murradoc Hill. Also, as you said, the water going through the dam is just a fraction of the total water flow down Ryan Court, most of which flows through a separate drain pipe.

It is reasonable to ask whether an unknown measure of improvement to the quality of an unknown (small) fraction of the total flow of water justifies the distress and disruption that has been caused to the local residents.


3. Safety and health issues with the dam
You said that there is no requirement to erect fencing around the dam because the angle of its banks conforms to the relevant standard.

Our response.
As you heard, parents are worried that the lack of any fencing around the dam means that children may slip on the banks, injure themselves or even drown. (Children in the local area have been used to playing in the area now occupied by the dam, because it used to be a little park, including trees planted by CoGG.) As you also heard, the dam disrupts an informal short cut across the creek that has traditionally been used by local people - especially local young people. The lack of any fencing means that people using this short cut - especially in poor light - may also slip on the banks, injure themselves or even drown.

Finally, while this wasn't discussed at the meeting, you will be aware that areas of stagnant water - such as this dam - can harbour vectors of various diseases, yet CoGG appears to have taken no measures to prevent this happening.

In a separate development, Ryan Court residents and Doug Carson each received a phone call from Cr. Macdonald saying that the dam would be filled-in and that the council would send a letter to that effect to residents by the end of the week! On Thursday 28 July, Ryan Court residents received a phone call saying that the letter had been posted and that they should receive it either the next day or the following Monday (1 August).

Watch this space!

Monday, July 25, 2011

DCSCA's 2011 Annual General Meeting

DCSCA held its 2011 Annual General Meeting on Wednesday July 20 at 7.00 p.m. at SpringDale Neighbourhood Centre in Drysdale High Street.

The meeting began with an illustrated presentation by local historian Dr. Bob Marmion, who has been researching the history of a WW2 aircraft detection device in Drysdale. Located in what is now the grounds of Bellarine Secondary College, the device was an early form of radar and was one of just nine such installations throughout Australia. People listened intently to Bob and asked him several questions afterwards.

DCSCA President Doug Carson reported to the meeting on DCSCA activities over the past year, including:
  • the highly succesful inaugural Festival of Glass in February, which attracted 30 exhibitors and 6,000 visitors
  • extensive work on developing detailed proposals for an Open Spaces Network, including contributing to the design of new signage for The Dell and to the Masterplan for Lake Lorne
  • updating Streetscape to Artscape - a joint program with SpringDale to create a collection of public art exhibits reflecting local people's memories of, and hopes for our towns
  • developing - again, with SpringDale - a local Economic Development Plan to complement the extensive housing development happening in our towns.
DCSCA has also worked with local people around specific issues, including the Special Charge scheme for Central Road, the open space in Springs Street and the new, Council-built 'dam' in the middle of Ryan Court.

DCSCA Treasurer Anne Brackley presented DCSCA's accounts to the meeting and proposed that they be accepted, which they were. DCSCA President Doug Carson then presented to the meeting a series of changes to the DCSCA Constitution (concerning membership eligibility, the timing of the AGM and the quorum for a Committee meeting), each of which the meeting accepted.

Finally, the DCSCA Committee for 2011-2012 was elected:
President - Doug Carson; Treasurer - Anne Brackley; Secretary - Patrick Hughes.
Committee members - Ian Cook, Bernard Filbay, Matt Green, Neil McGuinness, Diane Schofield.

DCSCA President Doug Carson then thanked everyone for attending the meeting and invited them to sample the refreshments. As they did so, people looked at displays by the Bellarine Historical Society, the local Harvest Basket Group, the Portarlington Lions and the Festival of Glass. They also looked at DCSCA Committee member Neil McGuinness's display of photographs of the new signage at The Dell; and his extensive display showing the network of walking/cycling tracks that DCSCA is proposing in its Open Spaces Network program.

Meeting the Minister

On 20 July, DCSCA and other members of the nine-strong Affiliation of Bellarine Community Associations (ABCA) sent representatives to central Geelong to meet state Planning Minister Matthew Guy.

The meeting - arranged some months ago - was at the Gheringhap Street office of David Koch (MLC). ABCA had asked to talk to Minister Guy about the proposal in the Liberal/National Coalition's election manifesto to create a series of 'Planning Statements', including one for the Bellarine Peninsula. In particular, ABCA wanted to know whether the creation of the Bellarine 'Planning Statement' would feature input from local communities and the Minister confirmed that there would be.

The ABCA representatives then explained the ABCA's particular significance as the only democratically elected and accountable body representing all the communities on the Bellarine. They highlighted the lack of such democratic accountability in other local 'community groups' and emphasised the positive role that ABCA could play as a conduit (alongside City of Greater Geelong Councillors) for the exchange of information and ideas between the state government and local people.

The Minister thanked the ABCA representatives for their time and for their views. He said that his office would be in touch at the time when the Planning Statement for the Bellarine Peninsula was being written, but he didn't know just when that would be.

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Hullo 'Central Walk', goodbye Structure Plan!

The recently released plans for the new Central Walk housing estate in Drysdale show that the estate will contradict several elements of the Structure Plan for Drysdale & Clifton Springs produced by the City of Greater Geelong (CoGG).

The land on which the estate will be built is bounded by Murradoc Road, Princess Street, Woodville Street and Clarendon Road. In the CoGG Structure Plan, this land is earmarked for high density housing and to that extent, building the estate is consistent with the Structure Plan. However, the Structure Plan states on several occasions that its intention is to retain the towns' traditional, rural character and to ensure a mix of accommodation. The plans for Central Walk show that it will meet neither of these intentions.

Central Walk developers Urban Land Developments claim that, 'Open space and greenery will feature prominently at Central walk and residents will enjoy the spoils (sic) of an extensive linear park, wetlands and central reserve ...' However, the plans show that the 'central reserve' is about the size of the neighbouring Aldi site; and while the 'extensive linear park, wetlands' is a welcome inclusion, it is just another way to describe the water course that flows through the land already and couldn't be built on anyway. Also, the plans suggest strongly that while Central Walk will be home to families, it will include no housing suitable for single people - elderly and young - who once again miss out on the chance to live independently in their community.

Further, CoGG has approved this 200-lot development while doing nothing to ensure that there are jobs available for the people who will live in it. This isn't the fault of Urban Land Developments - it's another instance of the council's lack of vision, which is turning our towns into 'dormitories' for Geelong and Melbourne. DCSCA believes that CoGG should be planning the economic development of our towns just as it is planning their physical and social development.

Finally, the lack of adequate public transport is forcing increasing numbers of people to drive cars to work, increasing the pressure on already crowded roads and, of course, increasing the emission of harmful greenhouse gases.

When the proposals for the estate were published last year, local residents had serious concerns about them. DCSCA's formal submission to the council highlighted the contradictions between the proposals and the Structure Plan. (We also criticised the council's poor public consultation on the issue.) Subsequently, we presented our arguments to a Planning Panel appointed by the state Planning Minister. The Panel recommended that the council approve the proposal, which it did.

CoGG has encouraged local people to participate in creating Structure Plans for their towns and tells them that these Plans will guide their area's development. However, the grand aspirations in these Structure Plans count for nothing as CoGG gives developers permission to cover the Peninsula with homogeneous housing estates, while ignoring the needs of single people and forcing increasing numbers of people to commute.

Monday, June 13, 2011

DCSCA proposal to break pool deadlock

The City of Greater Geelong (CoGG) asserts that there is insufficient local demand to justify building a $12m swimming pool and has advised local people to go to the pool at Ocean Grove.

In response, DCSCA has proposed a compromise: nominate space for a pool in the Masterplan for the proposed sports/recreation hub at the junction of Andersons Road and Grubb Road in Drysdale and and state how big the local population must be to justify building a pool. When the local population reaches that stated size, build the pool.

DCSCA is arguing strongly that there is clear - and growing - demand for a local pool and that the planned increase in population will increase the demand. It takes so long to build a pool that by the time a pool is finished, the demand - even on the Council's figures - would justify it.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

DCSCA at youth camp

DCSCA was one of several community groups invited to take part in a 'world cafe' at a youth leadership camp on 22-24 May near Torquay. The Bellarine Youth Development Network organised the camp for young people on the North Bellarine.

The 'world cafe' is a bit like speed dating for groups! Each community group sat at a table in a large room, the sixty young people at the camp were divided into groups of seven or eight and moved from one table to another, spending about seven minutes at each one. The result? A very lively and noisy crash course for each side!

DCSCA was represented by its Secretary, Patrick Hughes, who gave each group a three-minute introduction to community associations in general and the work of DCSCA in particular, then asked each group what sorts of changes they would like to see in their area. People wanted to see various facilities and amenities and these were by no means exclusively youth-oriented. For example, they called for more buses between Drysdale & Ocean Grove and between Drysdale and central Geelong (especially useful for people working in Geelong); more frequent mowing of grass around the tennis courts; some public toilets in the town; for the local skateboard park to be extended and kept clean and for a pedestrian crossing nearby; for somewhere in town to go to the movies; and for better street lighting to improve pedestrian safety.

As well as those specific items, people were also concerned with the overall feel of their area. They asked for a wildlife park, for more parks/open spaces in general and for 'just more colour!' This was good to hear, as it confirmed that DCSCA is on the right track in two of its projects - an Open Spaces Network, in which parks/open spaces (including a second Nature Reserve for the Bellarine) will be linked by walking/cycling trails; and Streetscape to Artscape , in which artists will work with local people to create and install art objects throughout our towns. Finally, there were calls for things which are perhaps more youth-oriented - a shop selling musical instruments, a Macdonalds, a nightclub and somewhere to just drop in, hang out and chill.

It was hard to tell what the young people at the camp made of the 'world cafe', but towards the end of their camp they will evaluate the whole experience and we will look forward to learning their views. From DCSCA's perspective, it was a very valuable exercise because it gave us a chance to hear directly from young people about what they want for their area. The DCSCA Committee is trying to involve younger people in its activities and this was a good opportunity to introduce ourselves and - just as importantly - to hear young people talk about their area and how DCSCA might help them to make things happen.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

DCSCA meets Cr. Rod Macdonald (6)

On 20 May, DCSCA Committee members met Councillor Rod Macdonald. This was the sixth of the quarterly meetings that DCSCA has initiated with the two City of Greater Geelong (CoGG) Councillors whose wards coincide with DCSCA's area - the other is Councillor John Doull (whom we met on 12 May).

Local amenities We asked when the Lake Lorne Masterplan would be implemented. CoGG's 2011/12 Budget includes some money to start work on some fencing, but no support for further work. Cr. Macdonald said that there would be a final consultation meeting with stakeholders (including nearby residents) in June or July 2011, following which the Masterplan would go to a Council meeting for approval. Once the Masterplan is approved, the Council will be asked to allocate money to its implementation.

CoGG's 2011/12 Budget allocated no money to implement the Masterplan for a regional sports/recreation hub at the junction of Andersons Road and Grubb Road in Drysdale. Cr. Macdonald said that money from the 2010/11 Budget would be used to complete the design of the Masterplan. The hub is planned to develop in three stages, but it depends on matching funds from the Victorian state government, which has made no commitment at this stage. Consequently, Cr. Macdonald couldn't say whether Stage One could start without those matching funds and whether Stage One will proceed without funds for Phases Two and Three being committed.

The Masterplan for the sports/recreation hub does not include a swimming pool, despite the clear - and growing - demand for one in Drysdale & Clifton Springs. We suggested that this is an issue for people not just in Drysdale & Clifton Springs but along the North Bellarine, because the Ocean Grove pool is over-subscribed and the pool in Portarlington has had an uncertain future. Cr. Macdonald said that the Portarlington pool's future was now assured and repeated the argument that there is insufficient demand to justify the $12m that it would cost to build a swimming pool in Drysdale & Clifton Springs. We said that DCSCA would persist in raising the matter, because of the strong local feeling about it. We also said that the area's expanding population meant that demand for a pool would only increase and that it takes so long to build such a facility that by the time it's finished, the demand - even on the Council's figures - would justify it. We suggested a compromise: nominate space for a pool in the Masterplan for the sports/recreation hub and then build it when the demand reaches an agreed level.

Local economic development
We said that the enormous success of the 2011 Festival of Glass (which Cr. Macdonald supported strongly) showed that people in the region are interested in glass and that there are lots of artists and craftspeople on the Bellarine who are using glass. Many of these people run small businesses already or, we suggested, would start new ones if appropriate support was available. We invited Cr. Macdonald to support DCSCA's proposal that CoGG uses the build-up to the 2012 Festival of Glass to announce a local business support program (e.g. advice and mentoring, assistance to explore new markets, rates relief) for small art and craft business on the Bellarine. Such a support program could link with the 'Made in Geelong' initiative, which offers small businesses short-term leases on empty shops in central Geelong, enabling small art and craft businesses on the Bellarine - individually or in partnerships - to test their economic viability in a town center.

Cr. Macdonald suggested that we should invite the CoGG economic development unit to have a stand at the 2012 Festival of Glass, which we shall certainly do. He discussed the possibility of creating a local business support program in the form of a web site designed explicitly to offer advice and information to people on the Bellarine who either own a small art/craft businesses or are thinking of establishing one. We said that we would develop the idea and contact him to discuss it further.

Finally, we suggested that CoGG could use its role as host of the forthcoming Sustainable Economic Growth for Regional Australia conference to showcase some initiatives around supporting local businesses to adapt to a post-carbon economy; and we asked whether there would be any community input into the conference, which is dominated by local and regional governments and businesses. Cr. Macdonald advised us to submit a proposal for a paper to the conference outlining our ideas; the conference committee (of which he is a part) would then decide whether to include it.

DCSCA's next quarterly meeting with Cr. Macdonald will be on Friday 5 August 2011. Any residents of the Drysdale/Clifton Springs area are welcome to ask DCSCA to raise any issue of concern with Cr. Macdonald.