DCSCA Committee members were among the
local people who met Shadow Minister for Public Transport David Hodgett on 10
May at SpringDale Neighbourhood Centre.
Mr. Hodgett was interested in local opinion on a Bellarine
Light Rail service; attendees favoured increased bus services, as they would be
more flexible.
DCSCA Treasurer Doug Carson has
suggested that a light rail service between Geelong and Drysdale would require
huge amounts of infrastructure, including stations (with associated parking),
rolling stock, drivers, auxiliary staff and perhaps a new tunnel between
Kilgour Street and the Geelong Station.
At first sight, then, improving and
extending the current bus network would be a simpler, cheaper and quicker way
forward. However, before a final decision is taken, there needs to be research
to discover:
·
potential routes for:
a) a
Bellarine Light Rail system
b) an
extended and improved bus network
·
likely patronage of the likely
routes in 5, 20 and 50 years time
·
costs of establishing and
running:
a) a
Bellarine Light Rail system – probably in stages
b) an
extended and improved bus network
·
potential funding sources for
the construction and maintenance of:
a) a
Bellarine Light Rail system
b) an
extended and improved bus network.
Population
drives policy
Population levels will determine the
area’s transport needs, so any decisions about the area’s transport services
must be set against the likely population of the Bellarine Peninsula and,
indeed, Geelong as a whole in 5, 20 and 50 years time. Therefore, any plan for
transport just on the Bellarine needs to be set in the context of a long-term
plan for transport in the area as a whole.
DCSCA Committee member Neil McGuinness
has suggested that such a long term transport plan should nor just expand the
present transport network but also innovate, including such ideas as:
·
extending the Geelong Ring Road
to the Bellarine
·
creating road, rail and ferry
connections to Avalon Airport (should these be provided publicly, privately or
in some combination?)
·
ferry services in Corio Bay and
Port Phillip Bay
·
cycle paths - recreational and
commuting
·
a road and rail connection
between Queenscliff and Point Nepean.
Better
transport for commuters or jobs closer to home?
Whatever
the content of a long term transport plan for the area, its major aim shouldn’t
be to improve commuting. Instead, it should aim to prevent ever-more people
commuting out of the area by creating business and jobs for the expanding
population of Geelong and the Bellarine Peninsula.
The
City of Greater Geelong has actively encouraged the creation of ever more
housing estates, home to many thousands of residents, without ensuring that
there are jobs to support them. The result is the creation of 'dormitory towns'
as an increasing number of people on the Bellarine joining commuters from
Geelong on the hours-long commuter trek to and from central Melbourne on roads
that were never expected to carry the current levels of traffic.
CoGG's
drive to expand the population of the Bellarine must be accompanied by plans to
expand and diversify employment. As a rule of thumb, a new job should be
created for each house built. That would at least start to match economic
growth with population growth; and transport needs would be for easy, fast
connections within the Geelong and Bellarine area, as well as between
this area and Melbourne.
Earlier articles on this blog have discussed a Bellarine Light Rail service. Search for these dates:
8 October 2011; 13 December 2011; 10 May 2013.